8

What are the reasons for choosing Joomla! Framework for a web application instead of using Zend Framework 2, CodeIgniter, Laravel etc?

Will its popularity increase sufficiently and will Joomla! site developers migrate from the to the soon?

4

The CMS provides a lot of chrome, features and functionality that are not in platform (eg. control panel, user management, etc.).

The Framework includes all the underlying structure including database functions, string manipulations, etc. but it isn't a CMS. (According to the Framework project, the Joomla CMS will be refactored to use the Framework functions, but currently uses only a small set).

So if you want a CMS, there's no reason to migrate to the framework (unless you want to re-invent the wheel). If you want to build a web app, web services or command line application using proven functionality, you can use the Framework to provide lots of convenience and utility functions, much like Zend.

Here's a thread with more information: What are the differences between the Joomla! CMS, the Joomla! Platform and the Joomla! Framework?

  • Actually most of the sites (and not blogs) do not need a CMS. They have a few static pages like About Us etc. so you need no article nor category. If a developer choose the J! Framework and writes a user management component for a project, he/she can reuse it in other projects. Also you can amend the current user component of the CMS and implement it in the framework. – Farahmand Aug 11 '14 at 22:23
  • @Fari-- if you wanted a simple site with static pages it'd be smarter to use jekyll or even AmazonS3. No need for CMS or Framework in that case, and no need for user management. – user101289 Aug 11 '14 at 22:36
  • Consider a large site with a few static pages. For example a Real Estate website which has "About Us" and "TOS" static pages plus 1 million "For Sale" dynamic pages. – Farahmand Aug 11 '14 at 22:52
  • I'd use IProperty. Then you get the benefit of a pre-made component as well as the option to add dozens of other components like newsletters that may be useful! – user101289 Aug 12 '14 at 14:42
  • I want to think more about the Framework in this thread. We know that the performance is important for mid-size and large projects. So I prefer to use a Framework. A component/package like IProperty can be written in the Framework. For a large project it is worth to create even an admin CP, etc. from scratch. – Farahmand Aug 12 '14 at 21:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.