The article actually starts with Media Contact and then everything under it except for the Sign Up for our NEWSLETTER and E-Help part. This isn't just happening with this article - it's every new article I try to create.
All thoughts or suggestions are appreciated.
edit: To add more information to this, I actually have an old backup where this very page shows the article properly - without the homepage. I checked the category for this article and it seems to be the same in both the working backup and the current site. Also the menu item it's assigned to and the article itself seems to have the same settings individually. The fact that new articles have this problem leads me to believe it's some global or default setting that was changed but I'm not sure what to check.