I have a strange issue with my login redirect. It WAS working perfectly, and I'm not sure when it stopped working, but now it leads to a few issues.
So I have a Menu item using com_users Login option. I set this to Guest so that it is hidden once a user logs in (I have done this many times without issue).
I am mainly using jReviews component on this website, but I can't redirect to anything outside jReviews either. There is NO caching and I can reproduce in multiple browsers in and out of Ingognito.
No matter what I put in the Login Redirect field on the options tab, it just takes you to the Homepage. If you click on ANY menu item after login, you get a You are not authorized message.
If I switch the menu item to Public from Guest, I am redirected to the Profile page and there is no error generated. This happens with or without SEF/URL Rewriting turned on.
I am beyond frustrated here. Nothing new was installed during the time from when it was working to not working. My work has been focused on CSS and layout of the jReviews and main template.
There are no overrides for anything other than front-end style and should have no effect on redirections.